Deal Design Intelligence

Intelligence methods for commercial partnerships

An illustrative case · For AI providers selling to pharma

How an AI vendor changed its pharma proposal

Maya, an account lead at an AI software company, has a drafting demo ready for a pharma prospect. Before writing the pilot proposal, she asks the buyer to walk her through a recent brief. What she learns changes the offer.

01 · Discovery

Maya tests the premise behind her demo

The buyer’s brand team wants approved updates sooner when a competitor’s drug is cleared for a new use. These short updates are called competitive briefs.

Key Assumptions Check

“Where did the last brief spend the most time, from request to approval?”

Maya’s drafting demo assumes that faster writing means faster approval. She asks the workflow owner how analysts find sources, check conflicting details, and get a draft reviewed. She requests work logs, analyst notes, and approval timestamps from six recent briefs before putting a scope in front of the sponsor. (U.S. Government, 2009)

02 · Vendor deal review

The vendor decides whether to keep the drafting offer

Back at the vendor, Maya and her solutions engineer use Competing Hypotheses to compare where effort and waiting might arise against the same records. Each explanation would lead to a different proposal. (U.S. Government, 2009)

Illustrative records from six competitive briefs
Evidence from the buyer Writing takes most effort Preparing sources takes most effort Review adds delay
Work log About three hours per brief went into finding documents and sorting out differences between them. Writing the first draft took about one hour.
Weakens

Writing took less recorded effort than preparing sources. A drafting pilot would target the smaller task.

Supports

Finding and checking documents took more recorded effort. The vendor still needs to separate those two tasks.

Tells us little

The log covers work before the draft goes to review.

Analyst notes Analysts gathered many of the same documents again for each brief.
Tells us little

The notes describe gathering documents, a separate step from writing.

Supports

Repeated searches add work before drafting. One place to search is worth testing.

Tells us little

The notes cover work before the draft goes to a reviewer.

Approval timestamps Five of six briefs were approved within one working hour of submission.
Tells us little

These records start when the finished draft is submitted.

Tells us little

By submission, the team has already gathered and checked the sources.

Weakens

Most briefs cleared review quickly. The sixth could reveal a review problem worth checking.

The offer changes from drafting to search

Maya drops the drafting pilot from the proposal. The work log and analyst notes give her a stronger reason to test repeated search. Her solutions engineer checks whether their platform can search a limited set of documents and link each result to its original source. They can scope that test while the buyer confirms which sources it can use.

Quality of Information Check

What Maya checks before promising a result

The log combines search and fact-checking. Maya asks the workflow owner to time them separately. She also asks why the sixth brief took longer to approve. If that brief reveals a recurring wait for a reviewer, she’ll revisit which problem the pilot should address. (U.S. Government, 2009)

03 · Sponsor proposal

Maya brings a narrower offer back to the sponsor

Maya presents a pilot the sponsor can evaluate with the workflow owner and the person who approves data use. The vendor will set up the search and track results with the analysts. The buyer will approve the source list and decide whether the results justify expanding.

The vendor’s initial idea

Write the first draft faster

Pilot a tool that drafts the update.

The vendor’s revised offer

Give analysts one place to search

“Let’s test search on your next three comparable briefs. Your analysts could find the current drug label and the company’s announcement in one place, with a link back to each document.”

What the vendor asks the buyer to approve
One workflow, a defined list of permitted sources, and time from the analysts and workflow owner to run the test.
What both sides measure
Compare similar briefs under the same review process. Track time spent finding sources, time spent checking differences, and total time from request to approval.
What would justify expanding
Approved briefs reach the brand team sooner. Reviewers can still open the original sources and spend no extra time correcting the work.
What if complete briefs were waiting for a reviewer?

If five briefs with complete citations waited two working days for review, Maya would recommend a different first test. The buyer could name a backup reviewer and agree on a response time, then track whether approval gets faster before funding software.

Report 01 works through the questions facing both the provider shaping an offer and the pharma team deciding whether to sponsor it. Explore the report.

Deal Formation: From Interest to a Pilot Decision, current report cover

From the current issue

Deal Formation

From Interest to a Pilot Decision

Written for sponsors and AI providers, Report 01 follows a commercial partnership from initial interest through the pilot decision. Its examples focus on U.S. pharmaceutical commercial operations.

48-page PDF. Eight structured analytic techniques. $99 for one named reader.

Read the five-page sample

Buy Report 01 for $99

Ernesto Encarnacion

The author

Ernesto Encarnacion

Ernesto brings more than 20 years of experience in life-sciences commercial operations. He graduated with honors from the University of Pennsylvania, where he studied Organizational Studies, and from Georgetown University’s master’s program in Applied Intelligence.

Privacy Notice

This notice covers the website and audience pages of Deal Design Intelligence.

Who operates these pages

Ernesto Encarnacion operates these pages personally under the Deal Design Intelligence brand and is responsible for the personal information described here. For privacy questions or requests, email [email protected].

What we collect when you subscribe

The sign-up form collects your email address, any strategic areas you choose and your agreement to receive email. EmailOctopus, our email service provider, records this information with your subscription status. Choosing strategic areas is optional; if you choose none, you receive the current enterprise AI partnership series.

We use this information to send the briefing: email insights and report announcements about the areas you chose. We do not sell it or use it for advertising.

Confirmation and unsubscribing

After you submit the form, EmailOctopus sends an email asking you to confirm. Your subscription starts only when you select the confirmation link; until then your address is held as pending and receives no briefings.

Every briefing email includes an unsubscribe link. You can also unsubscribe or ask us to delete your information by emailing the address above. After you unsubscribe, we send no further briefings.

Service providers

EmailOctopus (Three Hearts Digital Ltd, England and Wales) stores subscriber information and sends our emails as our processor. It states that contact lists are hosted with Amazon Web Services in the European Union, primarily Ireland. See the EmailOctopus Privacy Policy.

The sign-up form uses Google reCAPTCHA to protect against automated sign-ups. reCAPTCHA processes information about your device and browser, and may use cookies or browser storage, to assess whether the request comes from a person. See the Google Privacy Policy.

Cloudflare hosts and delivers these pages. It may process technical information, including IP addresses, web-request and traffic-routing information, to deliver and protect its services. See the Cloudflare Privacy Policy.

Proton provides the contact mailbox. If you email us directly, we receive your address and the content of your message and use them to reply. Emailing us does not subscribe you.

Cookies

We have not installed analytics or advertising pixels on these pages. The sign-up form and its bot protection may use cookies or browser storage under their providers’ policies.

Legal basis and international processing

Where EU or UK data-protection law applies, we rely on your consent to send the briefing, and you can withdraw it at any time by unsubscribing. We rely on our legitimate interest in operating and protecting this publication for site delivery, bot protection and replying to correspondence. Our providers may process information outside your country under the safeguards described in their own policies.

How long information is kept

We keep your subscriber information while you are subscribed. If you unsubscribe or ask us to delete your information, we stop sending briefings and act on your request. We keep direct correspondence for as long as needed to respond and resolve the matter. Providers retain service information under their own policies.

Your choices and rights

Depending on applicable law, you may have rights to access, correct, delete or receive a copy of your personal information, and to restrict or object to certain processing. Email us at the address above. Where applicable, you may also complain to your data-protection authority.

We do not use your information for automated decisions with legal or similarly significant effects. Linked websites have their own privacy practices. We will update this notice before changing what we collect or how we use it.