For AI providers and CRO partners
Shape the proposal around the evidence.
A pharma buyer asks for faster competitive briefs. Explore how the evidence helps an AI provider reshape a drafting proposal into a test of search.
Free case analyses and new-report announcements by email.
The competitive briefs case
Would faster drafting get the brief approved sooner?
The pharma buyer asks for faster competitive briefs. The AI vendor starts with a drafting proposal. Instead of treating that first idea as fixed, the vendor examines how analysts find evidence, write and obtain approval.
The first idea
A drafting proposal
What the work records show
Repeated searches for the same documents
The revised offer
Test search using sources the buyer is allowed to use
The offer changes when the evidence points to a different part of the work.
For CROs offering AI-enabled services, the same partnership questions can help examine a sponsor-facing proposition. The current report’s examples focus on commercial operations, rather than clinical-trial delivery.
Make the reasoning visible.
Work through a question, the available evidence and what to do next.
Structured analytic techniques, in use
Key Assumptions Check
Is drafting really the problem the buyer needs to solve?
The assumption being tested
The first proposal depends on a premise: faster writing will help briefs move through the workflow sooner. Make that premise explicit, then investigate it with the buyer.
What the evidence establishes
The buyer’s request describes a desired outcome.
What the evidence does not establish
It does not establish the cause of the delay.
Assessment
Faster approval is the goal; drafting is one possible cause
How the decision changes
Ask for workflow records and compare alternatives before fixing the pilot around drafting.
Competing Hypotheses
Which explanation fits the work records best?
How to compare the explanations
Compare drafting, source preparation and review against the same evidence. In this illustrative case, analysts repeatedly search for the same documents. Finding and checking sources takes more recorded effort than writing the first draft.
What the evidence supports
Repeated searches support a source-preparation explanation.
What remains unsettled
The recorded work does not settle the whole approval process.
Assessment
Source search is a better-supported starting point
How the decision changes
Propose a focused test of search using permitted sources. If completed briefs are mainly waiting for reviewers, investigate that delay before funding a search tool.
Quality of Information Check
What would the revised pilot still need to show?
What to check before promising a result
Searching and checking are different tasks. A search tool could save retrieval time while adding verification work. The pilot also needs a measure of the outcome the buyer originally asked for.
What the current evidence covers
The work log records effort up to draft submission. Separate timestamps record when drafts were approved.
What it does not prove
Those records do not measure the full cycle from the original request to final approval, or show that a search tool would shorten it.
Assessment
The pilot must test the benefit the buyer actually needs
How the decision changes
Track search time and checking effort separately. Measure the time from the buyer’s request to final approval before claiming that briefs move faster.
These examples adapt structured analytic techniques described by the U.S. Government (2009).
The partnership landscape
89%
What should you build together?
In IQVIA’s May 2025 survey of 107 senior commercial leaders, 89% said their organizations were already co-developing AI with external vendors or actively considering it (Kotakonda & Awasthi, 2025).
The finding describes these respondents, rather than all life-sciences companies. For a sponsor and provider considering a test, the practical question is which problem to tackle together and what each side needs to learn.
From the current issue
Deal Formation
From Interest to a Pilot Decision
Written for sponsors and AI providers, Report 01 follows a commercial partnership from initial interest through the pilot decision. Its examples focus on U.S. pharmaceutical commercial operations.
48-page PDF. Eight structured analytic techniques. $99 for one named reader.
The continuing series
Follow the reasoning behind a stronger proposal.
Subscribe to Deal Design Intelligence for practical cases, analysis and new-report announcements. Use the analysis to examine the next problem, evidence request and partner commitment.
New analysis as it is published. Full reports are sold separately.
Strategic areas are optional. Leave them blank for the current enterprise AI partnership series, or select only the areas you want. Broader areas are proposed future coverage.
The sign-up form is loading.
Read how we handle information.